The Executive Director Who Has Become the System
What helps executive directors stop carrying every donor relationship alone?
Nobody decides to become the system. It arrives in increments. Every increment is defensible on the day it is made. No board ever votes for the result.
This is not a failure of leadership. It is what happens when the knowledge has nowhere else to go.
How It Happens to Good Leaders
You wrote the first appeal because there was nobody else to write it. You kept the giving list in your own file because that was faster than explaining the file. You took the coffee with the Alvarez family yourself because they asked for you, and you were right to go. Each of those was the right call.
Nine years later you are the only person alive who knows why they give, what they will not fund, and that their daughter is applying to your program next autumn. Nobody asked you to become the system. There simply was not one, and you stood in the gap.
What It Costs in an Ordinary Week
A board member asks where things stand with a major supporter and you answer from memory, accurately, in front of everyone. Afterward he says, "You clearly have that one handled." The board concludes the arrangement is working.
Your development associate wants to help and cannot. The only thing you have to hand her is context: roughly 37 minutes of it per relationship. So you keep it. Sunday night you rebuild the week from your sent folder.
I think about the people in this position. The director who can name every supporter's children and has not been asked how she is doing in a year. The associate who is ready and keeps being handed envelopes instead. The supporter who has given quietly for eleven years, has never asked to be noticed, and deserves it anyway.
You cannot hand off a relationship that exists only inside your own memory.
Why the Problem May Not Be You
Lift the rug in an old office and you will sometimes find a single orange extension cord. A lamp, a printer, a space heater, and a kettle all run off it. The cord works. It also runs warm.
Nobody chose that arrangement. Somebody needed a lamp on in a corner with no outlet, and then somebody needed a kettle. The fix is not a better cord. It is another outlet.
What Changes When Knowledge Sits Outside You
The unit of delegation gets smaller, which is the whole trick. You are not asking anyone to take over the Alvarez family. You are asking a colleague to make one call, with the last conversation visible, a date attached, and their own name in the owner column. That is a much smaller thing to hand over.
Prioritizing stops being a mood as well. Record Monthly High Hope, Annual High Hope, Attributes, Relationship, and Engagement. Let the stable passes make the reasoning visible. Then use your judgment to choose a Personal Invitation, a Personalized Invitation with Follow-Through, or a Shared Experience and Invitation.
This is where my work often begins. How much of your supporter knowledge exists only inside you?
The C.A.R.E.™ lens
For an executive director, all five inputs are often stored in the same place, which is you. Monthly High Hope and Annual High Hope name your honest sense of what may be possible. Attributes are the stories you carry. Relationship is often trust in you personally. Engagement is your read on movement. Writing those down does not flatten your judgment. It makes your judgment usable by somebody else.
Try this Tuesday
Name the three relationships you would least want to lose. For each, write the five C.A.R.E.™ inputs, the last real conversation, and the next step. Then write a second person's name beside one of the three and hand that person the next step with a date on it. One relationship, one step, one other human being. That is the doorway.
Seeing this with your own names in front of you is usually where it begins. That is what the demo is for. Not because you need another system to run, but because the trust people have already placed in you deserves somewhere safer than one person's memory.
Keep up the good work of caring for people. It really does matter!
Kevin Eastway Founder and Principal, Kindred rOS
Three ways to stay connected:
- Subscribe to Fundraising from the Heart
- Follow Kindred rOS on LinkedIn
- Share this edition with a fundraiser who may need it