The Care Has Outgrown the System
How do nonprofits steward donor relationships when care has outgrown their systems?
Most fundraising teams are not short on care. They are short on somewhere to put it. The caring is intact. The carrying has quietly become impossible.
Why Good Memory Stops Being Enough
A development director once told me, almost proudly, "I know all 412 of them by name." She did. She could name who had lost a spouse, who had promised an introduction in June, and which couple was giving small gifts now and could give very differently in three years. Every word of it was true.
None of it was written down. It lived in a car ride, an inbox, a spreadsheet called donors_final_v4, and one very good memory. I spent years telling people that a memory like hers was enough. It is not.
Her 412 are the people I think about while writing this. The supporter who has given every year since 2014 and has never once been asked what drew her in. The couple who came to one event, loved it, and were never contacted again. The board member who keeps meaning to make an introduction and feels quietly bad about it. The steady, undemanding giver who has never asked for anything and should have been telephoned years ago.
When Growth Exposes the Old Way
Something shifts when a list crosses a line nobody announced. The relationships get more nuanced. The board wants better visibility. One person becomes the only bridge between memory and action. The tools that worked at 86 names cannot hold 412.
Nothing broke. The load changed.
Nobody did anything wrong here. The organization got better at its mission and more people wanted in. That is success, and it arrived with weight attached.
The care is still good, and the system is simply too small for the weight it is carrying.
Where Four Hooks Stop Working
Coat hooks come screwed to a strip of pine, four of them, spaced evenly by somebody who counted the people in the house that year. Then a child grows, a grandmother moves in, and January arrives. The fifth coat goes on the floor.
Nobody blames the coats. Nobody stands in that hallway wondering whether the family loves each other enough. Somebody buys a longer strip of pine.
Why the Problem May Not Be Effort
Outgrown care looks like a thank-you sent 23 days late with a warm handwritten line at the bottom. The person writing it meant every word. She only ever found a Thursday night.
It looks like a sympathy card bought in February and still in a desk drawer in May. It looks like a $50 monthly supporter of nine years whom nobody has ever phoned, not once, because she has never given anyone a reason to. Which of them never gave you a reason to worry?
The C.A.R.E.™ lens
Two letters carry most of this. Relationship measures how well this person knows your work and how well you know them, which is a different fact than how long the name has sat in the file. Engagement is about direction: closer to the mission this quarter, or quietly further away. Both readings are usually accurate and almost never written. When they live in one head, nobody else can act.
Try this Tuesday
Choose five relationships that matter this week. For each one, write three things: the last real contact and its date, the next right step, and the name of the person who owns it. Put it where a colleague can read it without asking you. Next week, keep only what actually happened. Notice which of the five moved.
A shared place for all of this is where it begins. How it works walks through what that looks like. Not because you need another tool to keep alive, but because the relationships you already hold deserve more room than four hooks.
Keep up the good work of caring for people. It really does matter!
Kevin Eastway Founder and Principal, Kindred rOS
Three ways to stay connected:
- Subscribe to Fundraising from the Heart
- Follow Kindred rOS on LinkedIn
- Share this edition with a fundraiser who may need it